Editor, Ceres Courier,
I am writing to express my concern regarding the events that unfolded during the city council meeting on August 26. Our guidelines do limit what can and cannot be said in public. However during this meeting, the mayor took it upon himself to respond to, comment on, and interrupt public comments, which to me appears to constitute a possible violation of the law.
According to California Government Code § 54954.3(c), “The legislative body of a local agency shall not prohibit public criticism of the policies, procedures, programs, or services of the agency, or of the acts or omissions of the legislative body.” This law ensures that every member of the public is entitled to their five minutes of speaking time, regardless of the subject matter. However, numerous interruptions took place, which is both disheartening and counterproductive to our community’s governance.
As a councilmember, I watched in disbelief, hoping the city attorney or city manager would intervene, which they did try. It is crucial for members of the council to listen to the concerns of the community without responding or steering the conversation. We must create an environment where residents feel comfortable sharing their views without intimidation.
Leadership involves listening, even when that means encountering differing opinions. It was embarrassing to witness members of the public feel apprehensive about voicing their concerns. While I appreciate the importance of the Planning Commission meetings, it is vital to remember that councilmembers should not attempt to influence votes in inappropriate ways. As pointed out by a community member, Shirley Rogers, the perspective she shared as a citizen could differ from that of the mayor, emphasizing that outside of the council’s vote, our input should be treated like any other citizen’s opinion.
The City of Ceres daily oversight and activities is led by a city manager, with all council members enjoying equal voting rights and providing general direction at the council meetings. The Brown Act does provide guidance and what can and cannot happen. The mayor, as the at-large elected official, should focus on fostering inclusion, not overshadowing the voices of the community.
It is crucial that we uphold the values of transparency and respect for public input moving forward.
Rosalinda Vierra
Ceres Council Member,
District 2
LETTERS POLICY: Letters will be considered for publication but must be signed and include an address and phone number. Letters should be 250 words or less and be void of libel. Send to The Ceres Courier, 138 S. Center Street, Turlock CA 95380 or emailed to jeffb@cerescourier.com.
